Panel OKs Dems' $3.5T Bill 09/26 10:43
Democrats pushed a $3.5 trillion, 10-year bill strengthening social safety
net and climate programs through the House Budget Committee, but one Democrat
voted "no," illustrating the challenges party leaders face in winning the near
unanimity they'll need to push the sprawling package through Congress.
WASHINGTON (AP) -- Democrats pushed a $3.5 trillion, 10-year bill
strengthening social safety net and climate programs through the House Budget
Committee, but one Democrat voted "no," illustrating the challenges party
leaders face in winning the near unanimity they'll need to push the sprawling
package through Congress.
The Democratic-dominated panel, meeting virtually Saturday, approved the
measure on a near party-line vote, 20-17. Passage marked a necessary but minor
checking of a procedural box for Democrats by edging it a step closer to debate
by the full House. Under budget rules, the committee wasn't allowed to
significantly amend the 2,465-page measure, the product of 13 other House
More important work has been happening in an opaque procession of mostly
unannounced phone calls, meetings and other bargaining sessions among party
leaders and rank-and-file lawmakers. President Joe Biden, House Speaker Nancy
Pelosi, D-Calif., and Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer, D-N.Y., have led a
behind-the-scenes hunt for compromises to resolve internal divisions and, they
hope, allow approval of the mammoth bill soon.
Pelosi told fellow Democrats Saturday that they "must" pass the social and
environment package this week, along with a separate infrastructure bill and a
third measure preventing a government shutdown on Friday. Her letter to
colleagues underscored the pile of crucial work Congress' Democratic majority
faces in coming days and seemed an effort to build urgency to resolve
long-standing disputes quickly.
"The next few days will be a time of intensity," she wrote.
Moderate Rep. Scott Peters, D-Calif., joined all 16 Republicans on the
Budget committee in opposing the legislation. His objections included one that
troubles many Democrats: a reluctance to back a bill with provisions that would
later be dropped by the Senate.
Many Democrats don't want to become politically vulnerable by backing
language that might be controversial back home, only to see it not become law.
That preference for voting only on a social and environment bill that's already
a House-Senate compromise could complicate Pelosi's effort for a House vote
Peters was among three Democrats who earlier this month voted against a plan
favored by most in his party to lower pharmaceutical costs by letting Medicare
negotiate for the prescription drugs it buys.
Party leaders have tried for weeks to resolve differences among Democrats
over the package's final price tag, which seems sure to shrink. There are also
disputes over which initiatives should be reshaped, among them expanded
Medicare, tax breaks for children and health care, a push toward cleaner energy
and higher levies on the rich and corporations.
Democrats' wafer-thin majorities in the House and Senate mean compromise is
mandatory. Before the measure the Budget panel approved Saturday even reaches
the House floor, it is expected to be changed to reflect whatever House-Senate
accords have been reached, and additional revisions are likely.
The overall bill embodies the crux of Biden's top domestic goals. Budget
panel chairman John Yarmuth, D-Ky., cited "decades of disinvestment" on needs
like health care, education, child care and the environment as the rationale
for the legislation.
"The futures of millions of Americans and their families are at stake. We
can no longer afford the costs of neglect and inaction. The time to act is
now," Yarmuth said.
Republicans say the proposal is unneeded, unaffordable amid accumulated
federal debt exceeding $28 trillion and reflects Democrats' drive to insert
government into people's lives. Its tax boosts will cost jobs and include
credits for buying electric vehicles, purchases often made by people with
comfortable incomes, they said.
"This bill is a disaster for working-class families," said Rep. Jason Smith
of Missouri, the committee's top Republican. "It's a big giveaway to the
wealthy, it's a laundry list of agenda items pulled right out of the Bernie
Sanders socialist playbook."
The unusual weekend session occurred as top Democrats amp up efforts to end
increasingly bitter disputes between the party's centrist and progressive wings
that threaten to undermine Biden's agenda.
Biden conceded Friday that talks among Democrats were at a "stalemate,"
though Pelosi and Schumer have been more positive in an apparent effort to
build momentum and soothe differences. A collapse of the measure at his own
party's hands would be a wounding preview to the coming election year, in which
House and Senate control are at stake.
To nail down moderates' support for an earlier budget blueprint, Pelosi
promised to begin House consideration by Monday of another pillar of Biden's
domestic plans: a $1 trillion collection of roadway and other infrastructure
projects. Pelosi reaffirmed this week that the infrastructure debate would
But many moderates who consider the infrastructure bill their top goal also
want to cut the $3.5 trillion social and environment package and trim or
reshape some programs. They include Sens. Joe Manchin, D-W.Va., and Kyrsten
In response, progressives -- their top priority is the $3.5 trillion measure
-- are threatening to vote against the infrastructure bill if it comes up for a
vote first. Their opposition seems likely to be enough to scuttle it, and
Pelosi hasn't definitively said when a vote on final passage of the
infrastructure measure will occur.
With each portion of the party threatening to upend the other's most
cherished goal -- a political disaster in the making for Democrats -- top
Democrats are using the moment to accelerate talks on the massive social and
climate legislation. The party can lose no votes in the Senate and a maximum of
three in the House to succeed in the narrowly split Congress.